Menu

Daylight Clarksville-Montgomery County

Independent, unofficial

Clarksville City Council meetings, 2016-01-04 to 2026-11-05

City Council

Meetings in 2023

Clarksville City Council. Each meeting shows its attendance, motions and roll calls in the order of the minutes, with a link to each page. Meetings whose minutes were not collected show their agenda only.

24 meetings on this page

Special session

Special session, 2023-06-20

Source: minutes PDF, 5 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09. Agenda: PDF, 2 pages (opens in a new tab).

Attendance

MemberRecordedSource
Wanda Allen, Ward 8 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-wanda-allen Report an error
Travis Holleman, Ward 7 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-travis-holleman Report an error
DaJuan Little, Ward 3 Absent p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-dajuan-little Report an error
Keri Lovato, Ward 12 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-keri-lovato Report an error
Ambar Marquis, Ward 5 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-ambar-marquis Report an error
Deanna McLaughlin, Ward 2 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-deanna-mclaughlin Report an error
Wallace Redd, Ward 4 Absent p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-wallace-redd Report an error
Karen Reynolds, Ward 9 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-karen-reynolds Report an error
Joe Shakeenab, Ward 11 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-joe-shakeenab Report an error
Wanda Smith, Ward 6 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-wanda-smith Report an error
Stacey Streetman, Ward 10 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-stacey-streetman Report an error
Brian Zacharias, Ward 1 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-06-20-special/att/city-brian-zacharias Report an error

Motions and roll calls

In the order they appear in the minutes.

Roll call: ORDINANCE 133-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 1, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p1-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 134-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 2, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p2-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 135-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 2, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p2-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 136-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 2, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p2-2 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 137-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p3-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 138-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 10 yes, 1 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p3-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 139-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p3-2 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 140-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p4-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 140-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion to amend. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p4-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 140-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 6 yes, 5 no, 2 absent).

Motion to amend. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p4-2 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 140-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion to amend. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-fa1a43d7-p4-3 Report an error

Committee meeting

Committee meeting, 2023-06-26

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 2 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Executive session

Executive session, 2023-06-29

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 5 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Regular session

Regular session, 2023-07-06

Source: minutes PDF, 11 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09. Agenda: PDF, 5 pages (opens in a new tab).

Attendance

Attendance for this meeting is under review and is not shown.

Motions and roll calls

In the order they appear in the minutes.

16 roll calls at this meeting are not confirmed and marked *.

Roll call: ORDINANCE 142-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 3 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p3-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 143-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 3 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p3-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 144-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 3 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p3-2 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 145-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 4 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p4-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 147-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 4 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p4-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 147-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 4 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p4-2 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 147-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 5 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 5, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p5-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 147-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 5 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 5, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p5-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 147-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 5 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 5, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p5-2 Report an error

Roll call: CONSENT AGENDA City Clerk Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 8 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 8, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p8-0 Report an error

Roll call: RESOLUTION 61-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 8 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion to amend. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 8, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p8-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 141-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 9 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion to amend. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 9, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p9-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 146-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 10 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 10, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p10-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 146-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 10 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 10, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p10-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 146-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 11 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 11, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p11-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 146-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: this meeting's attendance list could not be matched to the official record. Read it yourself (p. 11 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 11, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f21e4a47-p11-1 Report an error

Committee meeting

Committee meeting, 2023-07-13

Source: minutes PDF, 2 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09. Agenda: PDF, 6 pages (opens in a new tab).

Attendance

MemberRecordedSource
Deanna McLaughlin, Ward 2 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-07-13-committee/att/city-deanna-mclaughlin Report an error
Wallace Redd, Ward 4 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-07-13-committee/att/city-wallace-redd Report an error
Joe Shakeenab, Ward 11 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-07-13-committee/att/city-joe-shakeenab Report an error
Wanda Smith, Ward 6 Absent p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-07-13-committee/att/city-wanda-smith Report an error
Brian Zacharias, Ward 1 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-07-13-committee/att/city-brian-zacharias Report an error

Motions and roll calls

In the order they appear in the minutes.

No motions or roll calls are shown for this meeting.

Executive session

Executive session, 2023-07-27

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 4 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Regular session

Regular session, 2023-08-03

Source: minutes PDF, 11 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09. Agenda: PDF, 4 pages (opens in a new tab).

Attendance

MemberRecordedSource
Wanda Allen, Ward 8 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-wanda-allen Report an error
Travis Holleman, Ward 7 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-travis-holleman Report an error
DaJuan Little, Ward 3 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-dajuan-little Report an error
Keri Lovato, Ward 12 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-keri-lovato Report an error
Ambar Marquis, Ward 5 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-ambar-marquis Report an error
Deanna McLaughlin, Ward 2 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-deanna-mclaughlin Report an error
Wallace Redd, Ward 4 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-wallace-redd Report an error
Karen Reynolds, Ward 9 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-karen-reynolds Report an error
Joe Shakeenab, Ward 11 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-joe-shakeenab Report an error
Wanda Smith, Ward 6 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-wanda-smith Report an error
Stacey Streetman, Ward 10 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-stacey-streetman Report an error
Brian Zacharias, Ward 1 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-03-regular/att/city-brian-zacharias Report an error

Motions and roll calls

In the order they appear in the minutes.

2 roll calls at this meeting are not confirmed and marked *.

Roll call: ORDINANCE 03-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 10 yes, 2 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p3-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 04-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 7 yes, 6 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p3-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 05-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p4-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 06-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p4-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 07-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Failed (counted: 3 yes, 10 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p4-2 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 07-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Failed (counted: 5 yes, 8 no).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 5, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p5-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 08-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Failed (counted: 4 yes, 9 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 5, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p5-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 09-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Failed (counted: 3 yes, 10 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 5, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p5-2 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 09-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: a name in this vote does not match a member on the official record. Read it yourself (p. 6 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 6, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p6-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 147-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 8 yes, 4 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 6, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p6-1 Report an error

Roll call: PLANNING COMMISSION OLD BUSINESS (The following item was heard during Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: the minutes list a member as present but give no vote for them here. Read it yourself (p. 6 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 6, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p6-2 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 142-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 10 yes, 3 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 8, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p8-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 143-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 9 yes, 4 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 8, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p8-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 146-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 9, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p9-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 146-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 9, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p9-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 01-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 9, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p9-2 Report an error

Roll call: PLANNING COMMISSION OLD BUSINESS (The following item was heard during

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 9, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-a10f4b84-p9-3 Report an error

Committee meeting

Committee meeting, 2023-08-10

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 7 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Special session

Special session, 2023-08-10

Source: minutes PDF, 2 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09. Agenda: PDF, 1 pages (opens in a new tab).

Attendance

MemberRecordedSource
Wanda Allen, Ward 8 Absent p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-wanda-allen Report an error
Travis Holleman, Ward 7 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-travis-holleman Report an error
DaJuan Little, Ward 3 Absent p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-dajuan-little Report an error
Keri Lovato, Ward 12 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-keri-lovato Report an error
Ambar Marquis, Ward 5 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-ambar-marquis Report an error
Deanna McLaughlin, Ward 2 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-deanna-mclaughlin Report an error
Wallace Redd, Ward 4 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-wallace-redd Report an error
Karen Reynolds, Ward 9 Absent p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-karen-reynolds Report an error
Joe Shakeenab, Ward 11 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-joe-shakeenab Report an error
Wanda Smith, Ward 6 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-wanda-smith Report an error
Stacey Streetman, Ward 10 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-stacey-streetman Report an error
Brian Zacharias, Ward 1 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-08-10-special/att/city-brian-zacharias Report an error

Motions and roll calls

In the order they appear in the minutes.

Roll call: ORDINANCE 09-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 9 yes, 1 no, 3 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 1, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-966b8b8c-p1-0 Report an error

Executive session

Executive session, 2023-08-31

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 5 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Regular session

Regular session, 2023-09-07

Source: minutes PDF, 12 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09. Agenda: PDF, 5 pages (opens in a new tab).

Attendance

MemberRecordedSource
Wanda Allen, Ward 8 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-wanda-allen Report an error
Travis Holleman, Ward 7 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-travis-holleman Report an error
DaJuan Little, Ward 3 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-dajuan-little Report an error
Keri Lovato, Ward 12 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-keri-lovato Report an error
Ambar Marquis, Ward 5 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-ambar-marquis Report an error
Deanna McLaughlin, Ward 2 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-deanna-mclaughlin Report an error
Wallace Redd, Ward 4 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-wallace-redd Report an error
Karen Reynolds, Ward 9 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-karen-reynolds Report an error
Joe Shakeenab, Ward 11 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-joe-shakeenab Report an error
Wanda Smith, Ward 6 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-wanda-smith Report an error
Stacey Streetman, Ward 10 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-stacey-streetman Report an error
Brian Zacharias, Ward 1 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-09-07-regular/att/city-brian-zacharias Report an error

Motions and roll calls

In the order they appear in the minutes.

3 roll calls at this meeting are not confirmed and marked *.

Roll call: ORDINANCE 22-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: the automatic checks did not pass. Read it yourself (p. 3 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p3-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 23-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: the automatic checks did not pass. Read it yourself (p. 3 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p3-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 24-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p3-2 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 25-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p4-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 26-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p4-1 Report an error

Roll call: RESOLUTION 06-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 12 yes, 0 no, 1 abstain).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p4-2 Report an error

Roll call: RESOLUTION 07-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 5, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p5-0 Report an error

Roll call: MINUTES

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 5, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p5-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 147-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Failed (counted: 5 yes, 8 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 6, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p6-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 147-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 7, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p7-0 Report an error

Roll call: MINUTES

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 7, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p7-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 20-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 8, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p8-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 20-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 8, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p8-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 21-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 9, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p9-0 Report an error

Roll call: RESOLUTION 01-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 12 yes, 0 no, 1 abstain).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 9, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p9-1 Report an error

Roll call: RESOLUTION 02-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 9, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p9-2 Report an error

Roll call: RESOLUTION 03-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 13 yes, 0 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 10, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p10-0 Report an error

Roll call: RESOLUTION 04-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 8 yes, 4 no).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 11, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p11-0 Report an error

Roll call: RESOLUTION 04-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: the minutes list a member as present but give no vote for them here. Read it yourself (p. 11 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 11, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p11-1 Report an error

Roll call: RESOLUTION 04-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Failed (counted: 6 yes, 6 no).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 11, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p11-2 Report an error

Roll call: RESOLUTION 04-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 10 yes, 3 no).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 11, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-e40762d7-p11-3 Report an error

Committee meeting

Committee meeting, 2023-09-14

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 1 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Executive session

Executive session, 2023-09-28

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 4 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Work session

Work session, 2023-10-02

Source: minutes PDF, 1 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09. Agenda: PDF, 1 pages (opens in a new tab).

Attendance

MemberRecordedSource
Wanda Allen, Ward 8 Absent p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-wanda-allen Report an error
Travis Holleman, Ward 7 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-travis-holleman Report an error
DaJuan Little, Ward 3 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-dajuan-little Report an error
Keri Lovato, Ward 12 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-keri-lovato Report an error
Ambar Marquis, Ward 5 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-ambar-marquis Report an error
Deanna McLaughlin, Ward 2 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-deanna-mclaughlin Report an error
Wallace Redd, Ward 4 Absent p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-wallace-redd Report an error
Karen Reynolds, Ward 9 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-karen-reynolds Report an error
Joe Shakeenab, Ward 11 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-joe-shakeenab Report an error
Wanda Smith, Ward 6 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-wanda-smith Report an error
Stacey Streetman, Ward 10 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-stacey-streetman Report an error
Brian Zacharias, Ward 1 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-02-work-session/att/city-brian-zacharias Report an error

Motions and roll calls

In the order they appear in the minutes.

No motions or roll calls are shown for this meeting.

Regular session

Regular session, 2023-10-05

Source: minutes PDF, 9 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09. Agenda: PDF, 4 pages (opens in a new tab).

Attendance

MemberRecordedSource
Wanda Allen, Ward 8 Absent p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-wanda-allen Report an error
Travis Holleman, Ward 7 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-travis-holleman Report an error
DaJuan Little, Ward 3 Absent p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-dajuan-little Report an error
Keri Lovato, Ward 12 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-keri-lovato Report an error
Ambar Marquis, Ward 5 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-ambar-marquis Report an error
Deanna McLaughlin, Ward 2 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-deanna-mclaughlin Report an error
Wallace Redd, Ward 4 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-wallace-redd Report an error
Karen Reynolds, Ward 9 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-karen-reynolds Report an error
Joe Shakeenab, Ward 11 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-joe-shakeenab Report an error
Wanda Smith, Ward 6 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-wanda-smith Report an error
Stacey Streetman, Ward 10 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-stacey-streetman Report an error
Brian Zacharias, Ward 1 Present p. 1 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab)
Details

Fetched 2026-11-09.

Fact id 2023-10-05-regular/att/city-brian-zacharias Report an error

Motions and roll calls

In the order they appear in the minutes.

1 roll call at this meeting is not confirmed and marked *.

Roll call: ORDINANCE 29-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 10 yes, 1 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p3-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 30-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p3-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 31-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 3, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p3-2 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 32-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p4-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 33-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes Not confirmed

* Not confirmed: the automatic checks did not pass. Read it yourself (p. 4 of the minutes PDF, opens in a new tab).

Outcome: Not confirmed (not confirmed).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p4-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 34-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p4-2 Report an error

Roll call: MINUTES

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 4, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p4-3 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 147-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Failed (counted: 3 yes, 8 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 7, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p7-0 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 147-2022-23 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 10 yes, 1 no, 2 absent).

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 7, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p7-1 Report an error

Roll call: ORDINANCE 27-2023-24 Title not read from the minutes

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 7, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p7-2 Report an error

Roll call: MINUTES

Outcome: Passed (counted: 11 yes, 0 no, 2 absent).

Motion. Attribution under review.

Votes, alphabetical

Source: p. 7, fetched 2026-11-09 (opens the minutes PDF in a new tab) Fact id rc-f9fee1b3-p7-3 Report an error

Committee meeting

Committee meeting, 2023-10-12

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 3 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Executive session

Executive session, 2023-10-26

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 4 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Regular session

Regular session, 2023-11-02

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 4 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Committee meeting

Committee meeting, 2023-11-09

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 1 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Executive session

Executive session, 2023-11-30

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 4 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Special session

Special session, 2023-11-30

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 1 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Regular session

Regular session, 2023-12-07

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 5 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Executive session

Executive session, 2023-12-28

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 5 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Special session

Special session, 2023-12-28

Minutes not collected for this meeting. Agenda: agenda PDF, 1 pages (opens in a new tab), fetched 2026-11-09.

Unofficial copy. Official record: City of Clarksville CivicClerk portal (opens in a new tab).

Report an error on this page